Discussion:
Jeff Goldlum in Pittsburgh's THE MUSIC MAN
(too old to reply)
Bill
2004-07-11 19:44:39 UTC
Permalink
A dear friend who lives in Pittsburgh sent me his review of the show:

<< Last night I saw the first professional production THE MUSIC MAN
which I have ever seen!=A0 I've seen it done by colleges and summer
stock house, but until last evening I had never seen a pro pro.

The reason I saw this production was the fact that Jeff Goldblum was
returning to his musical theater roots, not to mention his hometown for
this show.

The thought of the gigantic Goldblum, who as an actor on film has more
than his fair quota of tics, tackling the role of Harold Hill seemed to
be one of those "What were they thinking?" propositions, yet, Mr.
Goldblum was quite good.

Casting this had to have been a bitch and true to my immediate thoughts
when I had heard that Goldblum was cast, yes, indeed, it was a Land of
the Giants cast.=A0 Ed Begley, Jr. (one of my faves from ST. ELSEWHERE)
stands about an inch taller than me - we exchanged kinds words as he was
on his way into the theater, both of us hoping for a ST. ELSEWHERE
reunion special.

Mr. Begley was playing Mayor Shinn - far, far better than Victor Garber
- with a touch of his father's spirit against the divine Ileanna Douglas
as his wife.=A0 Ms. Douglas was a revelation, to be sure; taking the
role and running with it, yet always true to the script.

Jeff Goldblum's charming fiancee, Katherine Wreford,=A0 posesses a
lovely soprano voice, quite rangy, and shone through with true acting
ability from the first moment she hit the stage to the final curtain
call.=A0 Her fine handling of "My White Knight" and the tenderness of
"Will I Ever Tell You?" were major highlights of the production.=A0
Very, very funny with her confrontation with Charlie, too.

As for Mr. Goldblum, he was not as miscast as Matthew Broderick had
been, as well as being as far away from Robert Preston as one can be.=A0
Thank goodness he brought quite a bit of originality to Hill, a con man,
yes, but, one who thinks on his feet and on the fly.=A0 It was
delightful to watch his Hill develop his scheme and to grow as a
character.=A0 With only slight vocal problems, sustaining throughout
"Marian the Librarian" did not detract too much, since his charisma
shone through.=A0

All of the character development paid off in spades once "The Footbridge
Scene" came about. . .the kiss which ends "Till There was You" was a
kiss out of THE PRINCESS BRIDE, absolute perfection.

Presented by Pittsburgh's Civic Light Opera and directed by Richard
Sabellico, the show's pacing was appropriately quick.

Goldblum has reined in his performance since the opening night review:

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/04190/343134.stm

There was no uncertainty in his Harold Hill last night.

The show will be playing through July 18th, and I might just take
another gander at it, but, for now, I am reticent.=A0 Oh, yes, I am
reticent. >>
..............
Drumm
Spelvin
2004-07-11 22:21:43 UTC
Permalink
Post by Bill
Thank goodness he brought quite a bit of originality to Hill, a con
man, yes, but, one who thinks on his feet and on the fly.
Well, yes, that's Harold Hill, as written.

Nothing will ever be worse than an amateur production of this great
musical which I once had the misfortune to see. The director got this
"great" idea to show us a new kind of Harold Hill and Marian Paroo.

Harold was a timid, frightened, tongue-tied weakling. (Yes, you read
that right!) Marian was a strong, no-nonsense, radical feminist.
(Actually, that isn't as far away from Marian as written as the Harold
was.)

So this Harold struggled to find his words, and kept flinching from the
mayor and Mrs. Shinn and the school board. He was only saved from
disaster from the take-charge Marian.

After I saw that, I swore I'd never attend an amateur production again.
It's been 15 years now, and I've kept my word and never regretted it for
a second. The professionals nowadays are lousy enough not to waste time
on amateurs!

I've often wondered why amateurs, uniquely in the world of entertainment
(including sports), think people should pay to see them. Would you pay
an amateur doctor or lawyer? Would you pay an amateur to fix your
plumbing? Amateur theatricals should be free. Better still, they
should pay us to sit through them.

Spelvin
Bushwhacker
2004-07-12 00:40:36 UTC
Permalink
Post by Spelvin
Post by Bill
Thank goodness he brought quite a bit of originality to Hill, a con
man, yes, but, one who thinks on his feet and on the fly.
Well, yes, that's Harold Hill, as written.
Nothing will ever be worse than an amateur production of this great
musical which I once had the misfortune to see. The director got this
"great" idea to show us a new kind of Harold Hill and Marian Paroo.
Harold was a timid, frightened, tongue-tied weakling. (Yes, you read
that right!) Marian was a strong, no-nonsense, radical feminist.
(Actually, that isn't as far away from Marian as written as the Harold
was.)
So this Harold struggled to find his words, and kept flinching from the
mayor and Mrs. Shinn and the school board. He was only saved from
disaster from the take-charge Marian.
The amateur production I saw wasn't the director's fault, except that he
picked a horrible Harold Hill, who compounded his ineptness by getting
hoarse halfway through.
Post by Spelvin
After I saw that, I swore I'd never attend an amateur production again.
It's been 15 years now, and I've kept my word and never regretted it for
a second. The professionals nowadays are lousy enough not to waste time
on amateurs!
I've often wondered why amateurs, uniquely in the world of entertainment
(including sports),
There are no longer any amateurs in sports, at least in those you pay to
see. Maybe there never were. (If they're not being paid directly,
they're getting contacts, and contracts, for future payments.)
Post by Spelvin
think people should pay to see them. Would you pay
an amateur doctor or lawyer? Would you pay an amateur to fix your
plumbing? Amateur theatricals should be free. Better still, they
should pay us to sit through them.
Spelvin
Steve Newport
2004-07-12 02:30:38 UTC
Permalink
***@nospam.net (Spelvin)
Amateur theatricals should be free.
---------------------------------
Then so should royalties and rentals.



http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com
Spelvin
2004-07-12 04:33:00 UTC
Permalink
Post by Spelvin
Amateur theatricals should be free.
---------------------------------
Then so should royalties and rentals.
Oh, no! If you amateurs think you're so great that you can do these
difficult roles in musicals, then you PAY for the suffering you put the
audience through.

Spelvin
Steve Newport
2004-07-12 05:37:07 UTC
Permalink
From: ***@nospam.net (Spelvin)
If you amateurs think you're so great that you can do these difficult
roles in musicals, then you PAY for the suffering you put the audience
through.
------------------------
I've mostly been paid. Even when I direct an "amateur" production. I've
seen amateur productions that were better to a man than many casts of
recent Broadway revisals. The directing is often better, too.
Particularly when my wife and I are involved.



http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com
Steve Newport
2004-07-12 02:29:09 UTC
Permalink
Jeff Goldblum was returning to his musical theater roots...the divine
Ileanna Douglas was a revelation
---------------------------------
?????????????????????



http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com
Spelvin
2004-07-12 04:33:35 UTC
Permalink
Post by Steve Newport
Jeff Goldblum was returning to his musical theater roots...the divine
Ileanna Douglas was a revelation
---------------------------------
?????????????????????
Some things it's better not to ask about. Let this lie there.

Spelvin
Steve Newport
2004-07-12 05:57:19 UTC
Permalink
From: ***@nospam.net (Spelvin)
Some things it's better not to ask about.
---------------------------------
I did like Ed Begley, Jr. on stage in THE CRYPTOGRAM.



http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com
Stephen Farrow
2004-07-12 20:34:01 UTC
Permalink
Post by Spelvin
Some things it's better not to ask about.
---------------------------------
I did like Ed Begley, Jr. on stage in THE CRYPTOGRAM.
I liked Eddie Izzard and Lindsay Duncan in "The Cryptogram". I just hated "The Cryptogram".
--
Stephen


I mock you with my monkey pants
Steve Newport
2004-07-13 01:10:10 UTC
Permalink
***@chass.utoronto.ca (Stephen=A0Farrow) <<<I did like Ed Begley,
Jr. on stage in THE CRYPTOGRAM.>>>
-------------------------
I liked Eddie Izzard and Lindsay Duncan in "The Cryptogram". I just
hated "The Cryptogram".
-------------------------
I've had better and worse Mamet evenings. BTW, Felicity Huffman
co-starred.




http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com

Loading...